FOSSA Logo

Guide to Android Open Source Compliance

Learn how to ensure complete compliance for your Android Open Source Project (AOSP) implementations, including generating comprehensive notice files and streamlining approval workflows.

Contents

0%

Introduction to Android Open Source

Android is an open source operating system for mobile devices and a corresponding open source project led by Google. The Android Open Source Project (AOSP) repository offers the information and source code needed to create custom variants of the Android OS, port devices and accessories to the Android platform, and ensure devices meet the compatibility requirements that keep the Android ecosystem healthy.

As the world's most widely used mobile operating system, Android powers billions of devices globally. AOSP provides the foundation that allows manufacturers to create customized versions of Android while maintaining compatibility with the broader ecosystem of apps and services.

Google makes the AOSP available to users under the Apache 2.0 Software License. This means the AOSP is free to use and alter, but users are required to generate notice files any time they make additions to the underlying code, ensuring proper attribution of components.

AOSP Development

Anyone is free to contribute code and fixes to the AOSP project repository, but Google oversees its general direction and the bulk of development. The AOSP regularly incorporates the latest bug and security patches for Android, making it a continuously evolving platform.

Android Open Source Development
The Android Open Source Project provides the foundation for the Android ecosystem

Evolution of Android Open Source Project

2007

Android Announced

Google unveiled the Android platform with the founding of the Open Handset Alliance.
2008

AOSP Launch

The Android Open Source Project was officially launched, making Android's source code publicly available.
2011

Android Fragmentation Begins

As OEMs created heavily customized versions of Android, fragmentation became a significant challenge.
2014

Android One

Google introduced Android One to reduce fragmentation and provide a consistent experience for entry-level devices.
2016

Project Treble

Google introduced Project Treble to modularize Android and make it easier for OEMs to update devices.
2019

Project Mainline

Google launched Project Mainline, allowing core Android components to be updated via Google Play Store.
2022

Modern AOSP

AOSP continues to evolve with stronger privacy features, optimizations, and enhanced support for different form factors.

License Compliance Challenges with AOSP

While AOSP provides immense value to developers and manufacturers, it also presents significant license compliance challenges. AOSP has an enormous amount of code, requiring developers to navigate complex licensing requirements that can create substantial overhead.

One of the most significant challenges is that AOSP-generated NOTICE.html files are sometimes missing details, making them insufficient for license compliance. For many licenses, a valid interpretation is that including only a copy of the license is insufficient—you need to reproduce every variant (e.g., different copyright statements) of the license present in the source code.

The Compliance Gap

When Google distributes AOSP, a library licensed under GPL will likely contain a NOTICE file with a single representative sample of the GPL license text. However, many legal interpretations require that all copyright headers referencing GPL in source files be included in the NOTICE file.

These challenges create several problems for organizations developing with AOSP:

  • Incomplete Compliance: Gaps in NOTICE files can result in non-compliance, risking legal, reputational, and financial consequences.
  • Slower Pace of Software Releases: Manually adding each license slows down releases, impacting time-to-market.
  • Error-Prone Process: AOSP's massive codebase and lack of automation make manual compliance efforts error-prone and time-consuming.

AOSP License Compliance Approaches

Traditional method where developers manually review and manage license notices for AOSP projects.

Key Features

  • No additional tools required
  • Direct control over license files
  • Simple for very small projects
  • No configuration needed

Pros

  • No cost for additional tools
  • Full visibility into the process
  • Complete control over the implementation

Cons

  • Extremely time-consuming
  • Error-prone due to AOSP's size
  • Missing notices can lead to compliance issues
  • Slower time to market
  • Difficult to scale as project grows

Automating AOSP Compliance

Given the challenges of manual license compliance with AOSP projects, automation has become essential for organizations looking to maintain compliance while accelerating development cycles.

AOSP Compliance Automation
FOSSA's solution for automating AOSP license compliance

An effective automated solution for AOSP compliance should deliver several key capabilities:

  • Complete NOTICE File Generation: Ensure that the NOTICE file includes not just package/component-level licenses but all relevant licenses in source files.
  • Workflow Support: Provide workflows for inspection, approval, and manual overrides if necessary.
  • Build System Integration: Parse the AOSP build system to accurately identify dependencies.
  • Time Efficiency: Reduce the time required to update NOTICE files from days to hours.

The Benefits of Automation

Organizations that implement automated compliance solutions for AOSP can expect:

  • 70% reduction in time spent on license compliance
  • Accelerated market delivery
  • Reduced compliance risk
  • Better resource allocation (engineers focusing on development, not compliance)
  • More comprehensive license tracking

Implementing AOSP License Compliance

Implementing effective license compliance for AOSP projects requires a strategic approach that balances thoroughness with efficiency. Here's a framework for establishing robust compliance practices:

  1. Establish a Compliance Policy
    Define your organization's approach to license compliance, including risk tolerance, approval processes, and responsibilities.
  2. Select the Right Tools
    Choose tools that can accurately scan AOSP code, identify license obligations, and generate comprehensive NOTICE files.
  3. Integrate with Development Workflows
    Embed compliance checks within your CI/CD pipeline to catch issues early and prevent non-compliant code from reaching production.
  4. Train Your Team
    Ensure developers understand the importance of license compliance and how to use the tools and processes you've established.
  5. Establish Review Processes
    Create workflows for legal review and approval of license obligations, especially for edge cases.
  6. Maintain Documentation
    Keep records of compliance activities, decisions, and generated artifacts to demonstrate due diligence.

Best Practices

  • Scan early and often during development
  • Create and maintain an approved/restricted license policy
  • Establish a process for handling compliance exceptions
  • Regularly audit your compliance artifacts
  • Keep your compliance tools and databases updated

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to take the next step?

Learn more about how FOSSA can help your organization